
Here are some excerpts from a great post published today by Christopher on his site at http://thanksgivinginallthings.blogspot.com/. The title is "Creation laughs back: animals, theology and animal saints".
I now know what others must feel, after having been laughed at for mentioning animal theology in a conversation. I have long heard others talk about derisive and dismissive encounters with "serious" theologians and scholars when the topic of animal theology is mentioned.
Considering animals in relationship to God is not something extra or foreign to Christianity. In my opinion, a serious doctrine of Creation cannot ignore the rest of the living world and the Creation as a whole and finally be Christian. Even rocks glorify God. And frankly, neither can a complete doctrine of Redemption or Sanctification. Indeed, to set up one's "serious" theology in such a way that one can ignore, dismiss, or deride creatures great and small, organic and inorganic, is a sign of the Fall and the effects of sin, alienation, and division. The rest of Creation pays dearly and regularly for our lack of relational recognition and failures in thankfulness...
When I'm driving and I notice a dead deer, raccoon, seagull, squirrel, or the like, I offer a prayer of thanks to God for the life of this creature and that God will greet him or her in His Kingdom...
I am part of a strand of tradition, the Benedictine, that honors this connection to the rest of Creation and is not threatened by the suggestion that God cares for each creature. A raven, after all, is God's messenger to Abba Benedict in his early monastic life and is often shown in iconography as friend and companion. We may not know the name of that raven, but given the desert penchant to understand that Christian life was to be lived in return to the Garden, I can imagine that Abba Benedict gave the raven a name. And as the icon shows, I'm certainly within tradition to imagine that not only Abba Benedict, but also the raven is raised up, is a saint.

Thomas Aquinas (1225-1274)
This is what happens by divine power in this sacrament; for the whole substance of bread is converted into the whole substance of the body of Christ, and the whole substance of wine into the whole substance of the blood of Christ. Hence this conversion is not formal, but substantial; nor is it contained within the categories of natural motion, but may be called by its proper name, transubstantiation.
Teresa of Avila (1515-1582)
In the presence of Jesus in the Holy Sacrament we ought to be like the Blessed in heaven before the Divine Essence.
Odo Casel (1886-1948)
When we go with Christ in his way he becomes contemporary with us. He is neither past nor to come but present to us; he is always with us. And not only his person but also his saving act belongs to this present. There can be no deeper communion of living than that we should share the essential life and action of another.
Constitution on the Sacred Liturgy (Vatican II)
...the liturgy is the summit toward which the activity of the Church is directed; at the same time it is the fountain from which all her power flows.
Catechism of the Catholic Church
1325. The Eucharist is the efficacious sign and sublime cause of that communion in the divine life and that unity of the People of God by which the church is kept in being. It is the culmination both of God's action sanctifying the world in Christ and of the worship men offer to Christ and through him to the Father in the Holy Spirit.
1396. Those who receive the Eucharist are united more closely to Christ. Through it Christ unites them to all the faithful in one body--the Church. Communion renews, strengthens, and deepens this incorporation into the Church, already achieved by Baptism. In Baptism we have been called to form but one body. The Eucharist fulfills this call: "The cup of blessing which we bless, is it not a participation in the blood of Christ? The bread which we break, is it not a participation in the body of Christ? Because there is one bread, we who are many are one body, for we all partake of the one bread" (1 Cor 10: 16-17).
1404. The Church knows that the Lord comes even now in his Eucharist and that he is there in our midst. However, his presence is veiled. Therefore we celebrate the Eucharist "awaiting the blessed hope and the coming of our savior, Jesus Christ, asking to share in your glory when every tear will be wiped away. On that day we shall see you, our God, as you are. We shall become like you and praise you forever through Christ our Lord.
Mother Teresa of Calcutta (1910-1997)
The humility of Jesus can be seen in the crib, in the exile of Jesus, in the inability to make people understand him, in the desertion of his apostles, in the hatred of his persecutors, in all the terrible suffering and death of his passion, and now in his permanent state of humility in the tabernacle, where he has reduced himself to such a small particle of bread that the priest can hold him with two fingers. The more we empty ourselves, the more room we give God to fill us.
When you look at the crucifix, you understand how much Jesus loved you then. When you look at the Sacred Host you understand how much Jesus loves you now.

Here is a string of short texts dealing with the Eucharist that I think would be useful to have in one place. They are not meant to be a research tool for academic theology but rather as aids for spiritual contemplation. Regular participation in the Eucharist is a crucial part of my own spiritual practice and I go on the assumption that Jesus is somehow really present in the consecrated bread and wine. When we receive the Eucharist we establish a mystical but very real connection with Jesus, and since Jesus is divine, with God himself. The Eucharist is thus a path to theosis or union with God. I will try to follow this up with other posts dealing with Anglican and Roman Catholic Eucharistic teaching.
Ignatius of Antioch (d. between 110-117)
Each one individually and all of you together are united in one and the same faith in Jesus Christ, Son of Man and Son of God, in obedience to the bishop and the priests, in harmony, breaking one loaf of bread which is the medicine of immortality, an antidote to death that gives eternal life in Jesus Christ.
Irenaeus of Lyons (130-208)
As far as we are concerned, our thinking accords with the Eucharist, and the Eucharist in its turn confirms our thinking. We offer to God what is his own, as we proclaim the communion and union of flesh and Spirit. For in the same way that earthly bread, after having received the invocation of God, is no longer ordinary bread but Eucharist, made up of two components, one earthly the other heavenly, so our bodies that share in the Eucharist are no longer corruptible, because they have the hope of the resurrection.
Ephraim of Syria (306-373)
Fire and the Spirit are in our baptism. In the bread and the cup also are fire and the Spirit.
Cyril of Jerusalem (315-387)
We pray God to send the Holy Spirit on the gifts laid here, to make the bread the body of Christ and the wine the blood of Christ. For the Holy Spirit sanctifies and transforms all that he touches.
Gregory of Nyssa (330-395)
What then is this remedy? Nothing other than that glorious body which showed itself stronger than death and has become the source of life for us. Just as a little leaven, according to the Apostle's words, is mixed with all the dough, so the body that was raised by God to immortality, once it is introduced into our body, wholly changes it and transforms it into his own substance...
The Word of God...once it became incarnate...provided his body with the means of subsistence in the usual suitable ways: he maintained its substance with the help of...bread. Even in normal conditions, when one sees bread, one sees in a sense the human body, since bread absorbed by the body becomes the body itself. So here, the body in which God had become incarnate, since it was fed on bread, was in a sense identical with the bread--the food transforming itself, as we have said, to take on the nature of the body. It was recognized, in fact, that this glorious flesh possessed the property common to all human beings: like them it was maintained with the help of bread. But this body partook of the divine dignity because of the indwelling of the Word. We are therefore entitled to believe that the bread hallowed by the Word of God is transformed to become the body of the Word...
As the bread transformed into that body was thereby raised to divine power, a similar change happens to the bread of the Eucharist. In the former case the grace of the Word hallowed the body that drew its substance from bread, and in a sense was itself bread. Likewise in the Eucharist the bread is hallowed by the Word of God and prayer...It is transformed at once into his body...as expressed in these words: "This is my body"...
That is why, in the economy of grace, he gives himself as seed to all the faithful. His flesh composed of bread and wine is blended with their bodies to enable human beings, thanks to their union with his immortal body, to share in the condition of incorruptibility.
Ambrose (334-397)
You here it said that every time the sacrifice is offered, the Lord's death, resurrection and ascension are represented, the forgiveness of sins is offered, and yet do you not receive this bread of life every day? Anyone who is wounded looks for healing. For us it is a wound to be liable to sin. Our healing lies in the adorable heavenly sacrament...
If you receive it every day, every day becomes for you Today.
If Christ is yours today, he rises for you today. Today has come.
John Chrysostrom (344-407)
On high, the armies of the angels are giving praise. Here below, in the Church, the human choir takes up after them the same doxology. Above us, angels of fire make the thrice-holy hymn resound magnificently. Here below is raised the echo of their hymn. The festival of heaven's citizens is united with that of the inhabitants of earth in a single thanksgiving, a single upsurge of happiness, a single chorus of joy.
Just as the head and the body constitute a single human being, so Christ and the Church constitute a single whole...This union is effected through the food that he has given us in his desire to show the love he has for us. For this reason he united himself intimately with us, he blended his body with ours like leaven, so that we should become one single entity, as the body is joined to the head.
Do you wish to honor the body of the Saviour? Do not despise it when it is naked. Do not honor it in church with silk vestments while outside you are leaving it numb with cold and naked. He who said, "This is my body", and made it so by his word, is the same that said, "You saw me hungry and you gave me no food. As you did it not to one of the least of these, you did it not to me." Honor him then by sharing your property with the poor. For what God needs is not golden chalices but golden souls.
The following comment by Fr John-Julian of the Order of Julian of Norwich (a small Anglican religious order) appeared October 22, 2007 in Derek Olsen's excellent site Haligweorc. I'm reproducing it here almost in full because I think it can stand being read, marked, and inwardly digested by the Marys and Marthas of the church--especially the Marthas, who tend to control the institutional aspects of it. Take it away, Father:
I went into my last parish with the commitment that I would place sacramental ministry (including its quality, nature, and frequency) in absolute primary place; secondly, I would preach/teach solid history, theology, and prayer--in the pulpit and in adult forums. I would refuse to promote other projects or programs of social service or justice or "mission" (including those of the diocese or the national church--and I filled the circular file with a whole lot of brochures).
Attendance almost doubled in 18 months! Pledges more than doubled. A ten-year loan was paid off in two years.
It took a little less than two years of this kind of focussed ministry before the questions started to be asked: "Shouldn't we be doing some kind of outreach ministry? Is there some way we can apply the Gospel to the community outside our parish? Could we undertake support for a missionary? (etc)".
It was on-the-ground proof of my conviction that deepening spirituality and theological learning will automatically produce a concern for social justice and action. (And my second conviction is that primary emphasis on good works does not tend to produce deepening spirituality and/or learning).
I know this position is considered heretical by many, but for me there really is a cause-effect paradigm here...True spiritual development will eventually not ALLOW one to ignore the social justice needs.
Eucharistic theology created with QuizFarm.com | ||||||||||||||||||||||||
| You scored as Orthodox You are Orthodox, worshiping the mystery of the Holy Trinity in the great liturgy whereby Jesus is present through the Spirit in a real yet mysterious way, a meal that is also a sacrifice.
|

The Uncreated Light: an iconographical study of the Transfiguration in the Eastern Church, by Solrunn Nes. Grand Rapids, Eerdmans, 2007.
A Norwegian Roman Catholic iconographer? But of course! In this reworking of her University of Bergen master's thesis in art history, Solrunn Nes gives us not only artistic analysis but a very useful and concise review of the Eastern Christian view of salvation history.
The Transfiguration has always occupied a position of primary importance in Eastern spirituality, and its feastday on August 6 is celebrated with great solemnity. By contrast, it was a minor liturgical event in the pre-Vatican II Catholicism of my boyhood. Jesus and some apostles went up a mountain and something weird happened to Jesus. After the Council, the significance of the Transfiguration had nowhere to go but down.
Nes' main point is that in Jesus divinity and humanity have been fully united. The light emanating from Jesus during the Transfiguration is his divinity, uncreated light pervading his human flesh. This divine light--understood as a real manifestation of God and not a created thing--is not limited to Jesus. Human beings who have attained great intimacy with God sometimes manifest the uncreated light as well. This is the traditional Eastern interpretation of the glow radiating from Moses' face after he came down from Mt Sinai. St Simeon the New Theologian (949-1022) manifested this light several times and (atypically) wrote about it. Perhaps the best-known account of this phenomenon is the description left by the 19th century Russian Motovilov of his meeting with his spiritual father St Seraphim of Sarov.
The artistic depictions discussed by Nes include two mosaics (from St Catherine's monastery in Sinai and Sant Apollinare in Classe, Ravenna), an Ottonian manuscript illumination (10th century imperial Germany) and wood-panel icons from medieval Russia. These latter are by Theophane the Greek (reproduced above) and Andrei Rublev.
The theological points of which these pieces are artistic expressions can be summarized as follows:
- God became human so that human beings can become Godlike.
- The light manifested by Jesus during the Transfiguration prefigured the light he manifested when he rose from the dead. That light, in turn, prefigures the light we will manifest at the general resurrection at the end of time.
- The general resurrection is not limited to humans but will include the entire cosmos, which will also glow with the uncreated light.
A very valuable part of Nes' book is the 51-page appendix which is a compendium of biblical and patristic texts dealing with the uncreated light.
You might also be interested in another book by Nes, The Mystical Language of Icons, also published by Eerdmans (2004). This book contains many full-color reproductions of her icons.

The jolly lad to the left is Richard Hooker. Richard lived from 1553 to 1600. He was ordained in the Church of England and later appointed by Elizabeth I as Master of the Temple, making him the chaplain of the Inns of Court, a key part of the English legal education system. After ten years he moved to a country parish near Canterbury where, in the remaining five years of his life, he managed to crank out his magnum opus, The Laws of Ecclesiastical Polity. Reading this is a tough slog, in that it comes off as Shakespeare written by a lawyer. Nonetheless, Hooker is considered the first great Anglican theologian. Even Pope Clement VIII was impressed by his work.
Hooker is widely credited with affirming that Anglican theology is based upon Scripture, Tradition and Reason, going so far as to create the analogy of a three-legged stool. Alas, this catchy image has proved to be something of an intellectual urban legend, for Hooker never said anything quite like that. See a recent post by Tobias Haller for a succinct discussion of the holy Hooker and his intellectual furniture.
Anglican theology has always struck me as more like trying to juggle three balls at once. The juggling act is complicated by the fact that, depending on the theologian, one of the balls is usually bigger than the others.
Evangelicals typically pay more attention to Scripture than to either Reason or Tradition. The Anglican Communion is on the verge of imploding in large part because some evangelicals, unable to compromise on " the authority of Scripture", are unwilling to gather around the altar with gays, lesbians, and those who support their inclusion in the church. Recently Nigerian Bishop Isaac Orama let fly with an exceptionally vicious example of where this can all lead which can be read about here.
Anglo-Catholics tend to give pride of place to Tradition, especially those aspects of it concerned with the sacraments, with liturgy, and with spirituality. As with evangelicals, there are several varieties of Anglo-Catholics, some of whom are less brain-dead than others. For some AC's, unfortunately, Tradition boils down to lace surplices, fiddleback chasubles, semi-closeted homosexuality, the Anglican Missal, and no girls allowed in the sanctuary (except for the altar guild, of course).
Liberal or broad-church Anglicans emphasize human Reason (with experience as a subset of reason) as the key factor in the interpretation of Scripture and theological Tradition. Members of this faction who've gone off the rails would include the late Bishop Pike, the present-day Bishop Spong, and those sympathetic with the work of the Jesus Seminar. Thes folks assume the validity of secular rationalism and assert that Christianity must adjust itself to post-Enlightenment worldviews or else become irrelevant. The net result, IMHO, is Unitarianism in drag.
Bearing this in mind, I am quite willing to admit that, concerning the issue of homosexuality, reason/experience trumps both Scripture and Tradition. Many Anglicans, both gay and straight, point to the existence of committed gay and lesbian monogamous relationships (usually in the face of overwhelming societal disapproval) as evidence that the anti-gay sanctions proclaimed for so long by the church must, at the very least, be rethought.
An excellent statement of this position can be found in an essay by Luke Timothy Johnson appearing in Commonweal, long one of the main house-organs for thinking Roman Catholics. Johnson is a Catholic himself, a professor at Emory University, and a former Benedictine monk. He left the monastery to marry a divorcee with six kids. They're still an item.
Johnson's essay is available here.
Christ of Hagia Sophia
Contributors
- Joe Rawls
- I'm an Anglican layperson with a great fondness for contemplative prayer and coffeehouses. My spirituality is shaped by Benedictine monasticism, high-church Anglicanism, and the hesychast tradition of Eastern Orthodoxy. I've been married to my wife Nancy for 38 years.
Archives
Categories
- theosis
- eucharist
- Resurrection
- Benedictines
- Judaism
- Trinity
- liturgy
- Anglicanism
- Christmas
- Transfiguration
- baptism
- monasticism
- Andrewes
- Ascension
- Irenaeus
- Jesus Prayer
- Kallistos Ware
- Rowan Williams
- creed
- icons
- universalism
- Book of Common Prayer
- Climacus
- Easter
- Merton
- Rublev
- Teresa of Avila
- Underhill
- desert fathers
- incarnation
- mysticism
- repentance
- science
- Aquinas
- Athanasius
- Athos
- Cabasilas
- Clement
- Daily Office
- Gregory the Great
- Isaac of Nineveh
- Jesus seminar
- Julian
- Lossky
- Luther
- Pachomius
- Pentecost
- Ramsey
- Rule
- Wright
- angels
- christology
- ecology
- eschatology
- evangelicals
- hesychasm
- kenosis
- lectio divina
- litany
- nativity
Nicholas Ferrar
Older Posts
- "A Great Understanding"
- A Jew on the Resurrection
- A Wild and Crazy God
- Advent Repentance
- All Saints
- Amen, Brother, and Pax Vobiscum!
- Anglican Hermits in the Big Apple
- Anglican Theology: Follow the Bouncing Balls
- Anglican Values
- Anglo-Catholic Identity
- Animal Saints
- Anthony Bloom on the Transfiguration
- Ascension and the Sanctification of Matter
- Ascesis and Theosis
- Athanasius on the Trinity
- Athonite Benedictines
- Augustine on the Ascension
- Authentic Mysticism
- Baptism and Kenosis
- Bede on the Transfiguration
- Begging for Mercy in the Jesus Prayer
- Being About My Father's Busy-ness
- Benedict and the East
- Benedict on Humility in Christ
- Benedictine Stability
- Bishop Andrewes' Chapel
- Bishop Hilarion on Prayer and Silence
- Blessed John Henry Newman
- Booknote: In the Heat of the Desert
- Booknote: Short Trip to the Edge
- Booknote: The Essential Writings of Christian Mysticism
- Booknote: The Uncreated Light
- Boredom Eternal?
- Born-again Sacramentalism
- Bulgakov on the Incarnation
- Camaldoli's Eastern Roots
- Chalcedon and the Real World
- Chittister on Benedictine Prayer
- Christmas Foreshadows Easter
- Clairvaux Quotes
- Climacus Condensed
- Cloister of the Heart
- Colliander on the Jesus Prayer
- Communion After Baptism
- Communion Prayers
- Creeping Up the Ladder
- Daily Readings from the Rule of Benedict
- Darwin and the Rabbi
- Dueling Worldviews
- Ephrem the Syrian
- Esoteric and Exoteric
- Essence, Energies, Theosis
- Eucharist and Creed
- Eucharist and Ecology
- Eucharistic Quotes: Anglican
- Eucharistic Quotes: Patristic
- Eucharistic Quotes: Roman Catholic
- Evagrius on Prayer
- Exaltation of the Holy Cross
- George Herbert
- Getting Our Priorities Straight
- God in Creation
- Great O Antiphons
- Gregory of Nazianzus on Baptism
- Gregory on Michael
- Gregory the Great on Angels
- Healing Words
- Heschel on Prayer
- Hildegard on the Trinity
- Holy Fear(s)
- Incarnation and Theosis
- Irenaeus and the Atonement
- Irenaeus on Pentecost
- Irenaeus on the Trinity
- Jewish Figures in the Eastern Liturgy
- John Donne
- John of the Cross
- Julian and the Motherhood of God
- Kallistos Ware on the Jesus Prayer
- Lancelot Andrewes on the Resurrection
- Lancelot Andrewes on Theosis and Eucharist
- Latin Strikes Back
- Lectio Divina Resources
- Liber Precum Publicarum
- Litany of St Benedict
- Living in the Present Moment
- Lossky on the Transfiguration
- Luther and Theosis
- Marilyn Adams on the Resurrection
- Merton and Sophia
- Monk-animals
- Monks on Silence
- Monks, in a Nutshell
- Monstrance as Mandala
- Moralistic Therapeutic Deism
- More on Green Orthodoxy
- Myrrh-bearing Witnesses
- Mystical Tofu
- Newark's mea culpa
- Nicholas Ferrar
- No Free Passes for Skeptics
- Of Limited Pastoral Use
- Old Rites, Young Bodies
- Olivier Clement on the Eucharist
- Orthodox Thought Control
- Pachomius
- Papal Fashion Statements
- Paschal Proclamation
- Passover and Eucharist
- Patriarch's Paschal Proclamation
- Poetry by Herbert
- Polkinghorne on Creationism
- Polkinghorne on the Resurrection
- Prayers to St Benedict
- Praying With the Trinity Icon
- Priorities
- Ramsey on Anglican Theology
- RB and BCP
- Recovering Secularists
- Reinventing the Monastic Wheel
- Rescuing Darwin
- Resurrection in Judaism and Christianity
- Roman Christmas Proclamation
- Rowan on Wisdom, Science, and Faith
- Rowan Williams on Teresa of Avila
- Rowan Williams on the Resurrection
- Rublev's Circle of Love
- Rublev's Sacred Geometry
- Salvation for All Revisited
- Salvation for Everyone?
- Seraphim of Sarov
- Seven Lenten Theses
- Shell Games
- Sinai Pantocrator
- Spiritual and Religious
- St Benedict the Bridge Builder
- St Ignatius Brianchaninov on the Jesus Prayer
- St John Cassian on Prayer
- St John of Damascus
- St Joseph's Womb
- St Padraig's Creed
- Sweetman on Faith and Reason
- Symeon on the Eucharist
- Sympathy for the Devil?
- Teresa of Avila
- The Anglican Great Litany
- The Dormition of the Theotokos...
- The Green Patriarch
- The Jesus Prayer
- The Mystery of Holy Saturday
- The Resurrection is Not a Bludgeon
- Theology Isn't a Head Trip
- Theology Lite?
- Theosis and Eucharist
- Theosis and the Name of Jesus
- Theosis for Everyone
- Theosis in the Catholic Catechism
- Theosis: What it's all about
- Thomas Merton on the Jesus Prayer
- Three Faces of CS Lewis
- Transfiguration and Suffering
- Transfiguration Quotes
- Trinitarian Dance
- Two Sides of the Same Coin
- Underhill on Theosis
- Underhill on Worship
- Victory in Christ
- Virgin of the Sign
- What's Really Important?
- Why the Creed Matters
- Wright on the Resurrection
- Young Geezers and the Liturgy
- Zizioulas on Baptism and Eucharist
Lancelot Andrewes
Anglicans
- A Desert Father
- A Red State Mystic
- Affirming Catholicism
- All Things Necessary
- Anglican Communion
- Anglican Eucharistic Theology
- Anglican Society for the Welfare of Animals
- Anglo-Orthodoxy
- Catholicity and Covenant
- Celtic-Orthodox Connections
- Chantblog
- Chicago Consultation
- Creedal Christian
- Don't Shoot the Prophet
- Episcopal Cafe
- Episcopal News Service
- Evelyn Underhill
- Faith in the 21st Century
- For All the Saints
- In a Godward Direction
- Inclusive Orthodoxy
- Interrupting the Silence
- Into the Expectation
- N. T. Wright
- Nicholas Ferrar and Little Gidding
- Preces Privatae
- Project Canterbury
- Society for Eastern Rite Anglicanism
- Society of Catholic Priests
- St Bede's Breviary
- Taize Community
- The Anglo-Catholic Vision
- The Benedictine Spirit in Anglicanism
- The Conciliar Anglican
- The Daily Office
- The Hackney Hub
- The Jesus Prayer (Anglican perspectives)
- The St Bede Blog
- Thinking Anglicans
St Benedict Giving the Rule
St Gregory Palamas
Eastern Christians
- A Spoken Silence
- A Vow of Conversation
- Ancient Christian Defense
- Ancient Faith Radio
- Antiochian Orthodox Church
- Coptic Church
- East Meets East
- Eclectic Orthodoxy
- Ecumenical Patriarchate
- Glory to God for All Things
- Hesychasm
- Jewish Roots of Eastern Christian Mysticism
- Malankara Syriac Church
- Mar Thoma Syrian Church of Malabar
- Monachos
- Mount Athos
- Mystagogy
- Nestorian Church
- Occidentalis
- Orthodox Arts Journal
- Orthodox Links
- Orthodox Peace Fellowship
- Orthodox Way of Life
- Orthodox Western Rite
- OrthodoxWiki
- Pravoslavie
- Public Orthodoxy
- Salt of the Earth
- The Jesus Prayer
St Gregory the Great